Science 6 min read

Nature Says Academies Named Researchers Without Consent and Offered Others Paid Memberships

A Nature investigation links several grand-sounding academies to shared virtual mailboxes and one recurring name, after well-known scientists were elected, or named to leadership, without being asked.

Nadia Rahim
Data & Statistics Analyst
Published 29 Sep 2026, 6:32 AM (SGT)
Share:
A silver medal engraved with the word winner A silver medal engraved with the word winner Photo by AxxLC on Pixabay
Advertisement

29 SEP 2026 — Several grand-sounding academies elected well-known scientists without asking, and at least one named a scientist to its leadership without her consent, according to a Nature investigation published on 25 September. Other researchers were offered memberships for a fee. Nature linked several of these bodies to a set of virtual mailbox addresses and to one name that recurs across them.

Correction — 2 October 2026

This article was revised after a complaint from the National Academy of Artificial Intelligence (NAAI). The original headline said the academies sold titles. Nature reports that paid memberships were offered, and that it identified no one who admitted paying, so the headline now says that. The original text also left it unclear which academy offered Julia Hirschberg a paid chair's role and listed her on its leadership page: Nature attributes that to the European Academy of Engineering, not to NAAI. We have also attributed the opening description to Nature, added Michael Chu's account of his role at NAAI and Michael Jordan's later removal from NAAI's website, and added NAAI's response.

Leading universities announced the honours in press releases. One of the academies held its 2026 annual meeting in Singapore.

How it looked from the inside

In July, Columbia University computer scientist Julia Hirschberg was told she had been elected to the European Academy of Engineering, days after an election to the Austrian Academy of Engineering. In 2025 she had been elected to the National Academy of Artificial Intelligence. Columbia announced the honours.

Then, Nature reports, the European Academy of Engineering offered her a paid rotating chair's role, and she found her name already at the top of that academy's leadership page. She had never agreed to the post or attended a single meeting, and nobody had asked her for references.

Nature found more than 30 university press releases, including Columbia's, celebrating faculty honours from two of these bodies, the European Academy of Engineering and the National Academy of Artificial Intelligence.

What Nature found

According to Nature, the two academies' websites claimed partnerships with bodies such as the US National Academy of Sciences, the Royal Academy of Engineering and the American Meteorological Society. Five of the named organisations told Nature they knew of no such partnership.

Nature found that the European Academy of Engineering gives a virtual mailbox as its address, and that no organisation of that name appears in Sweden's public register. The photograph of its supposed building turned out to be a doctored image of the University of Gothenburg, and parts of its website had been copied from the US National Academies.

The name that appears most often in connection with these bodies, Nature reports, is Michael Chu, also known as Chaoyang Zhu. Public records show the National Academy of Artificial Intelligence uses the same virtual mailbox address in Colorado as the International Institute of Engineering Psychology, which Chu has listed as his research affiliation. Chu told Nature that he holds direct operational responsibility only for that institute, and that he resigned from an administrative role at NAAI in May 2026. Nature found that he continued to send official NAAI communications after that date.

30+University press releases celebrating these honours

US$600Top membership fee listed by the AI academy

US$10,000Price of the academy's advertised virtual PhD

SingaporeVenue of the AI academy's 2026 annual meeting

The business model

Nature describes a pattern in which prominent scientists receive unsolicited, fee-free honours that give the societies credibility, while others are offered paid memberships and credentials. According to Nature, the AI academy's website lists fees from US$30 a year for a student affiliate to a US$600 initiation fee for full membership, plus a US$10,000 virtual PhD and a US$2,000 virtual postdoc.

Nature found dozens of researchers in China and Pakistan listing fellowships and awards from these bodies on their CVs. Fan Xiudi, an education-policy specialist at Tongji University in Shanghai, told Nature that research evaluation in China relies heavily on honorary titles, which creates a market for them. Nature did not identify anyone who admitted paying.

Advertisement

Computer scientist Michael Jordan had agreed to join NAAI and recorded a statement for a 2025 conference. In July 2026 he asked to be removed as a member because of the fees. "Paying for titles is anathema to me," he told Nature. Instead, Nature reports, the academy listed him as a featured speaker at a paid October conference without his knowledge. He has since had his name removed from its website.

NAAI's response

In a complaint to RECATOOLS on 2 October, the NAAI Secretariat disputed any suggestion that ordinary membership dues are evidence of buying an academic title. It said dues support the academy's operations and academic activities, and that most early members received full or partial dues waivers. It said its postdoctoral programme has a fee structure, but that only two applicants were admitted over the past year or so, and that both received full tuition waivers. These are NAAI's statements, and we have not independently verified them.

The Singapore meeting

Moshe Vardi of Rice University attended the AI academy's 2026 annual meeting in Singapore online, expecting an international summit. He found about two dozen researchers, meeting mostly in Chinese, organised by Chu and an assistant.

Nature does not say whether the organisations have any registration in Singapore.

How to check an honour

An unsolicited election with no nomination process is the first warning sign in Nature's reporting. The others are easy to test: ask the listed partners whether the partnership exists, and look up whether the address is an office or a mailbox. A real academy's founders and members show up in their own biographies. If a university honours office has never heard of a society, look again before the press release goes out.

Examedia, an Argentine outlet, has since profiled Chu on the back of Nature's findings, and the investigation continues to invite tips from researchers.

Advertisement
Nadia Rahim
Data & Statistics Analyst

Nadia Rahim covers statistics, data literacy, measurement, and how published numbers get misread for RECATOOLS.

View author profile → · Editorial policy

About this byline Nadia Rahim is a RECATOOLS editorial persona for statistics and data-literacy coverage. Articles are produced and reviewed under RECATOOLS editorial supervision.

Corrections policy

Advertisement