The NFL passer rating, adopted in 1973, scores a passer from five box-score numbers on a scale from 0 to 158.3. Below its caps it can be read in passing yards, building on Roger W. Johnson's 1993 note showing that it is then one straight weighted sum. Counted that way, a completion is worth 20 yards. A touchdown adds an 80-yard bonus on top. An interception costs 100. So the interception penalty is 1.25 times the touchdown bonus, by our arithmetic, although a whole touchdown pass of any length still outweighs it. Put the college formula on the same footing and the ratio falls to 0.61.
Every part of the rating tops out at 2.375
The formula here is the text of the NFL Record & Fact Book (2010), as reproduced by the Pro Football Hall of Fame in its article "NFL's Passer Rating". The page says the standard was "based on statistical achievements of all qualified pro passers since 1960", and that the system is used "to rate passers" rather than quarterbacks.
Four per-attempt rates each become a score. Completion percentage minus 30 is multiplied by 0.05. Yards per attempt minus 3 is multiplied by 0.25. Touchdown percentage is multiplied by 0.2, and interception percentage times 0.25 is subtracted from 2.375. Each score is held between 0 and 2.375, then the four are added, divided by six and multiplied by 100. Four capped scores make 158.3.
The Hall's worked example is Manning's 2004 season: 336 of 497 for 4,557 yards, 49 touchdowns and 10 interceptions. We recompute it to 121.1058, which rounds to the page's 121.1. None of its four parts reaches a cap.
An unsaturated rating turns every event into passing yards
When no part sits at a cap or floor, the four scores collapse into one sum. Johnson gave it in "How Does the NFL Rate the Passing Ability of Quarterbacks?" in The College Mathematics Journal (1993), and his StatLib entry at Carnegie Mellon prints the uncapped rating as one fraction over 12, as does the Chance Project page at Dartmouth built on his data.
Johnson's fraction rearranges, term for term, into rating = 100/24 × (0.5 + (20 × completions + yards + 80 × touchdowns − 100 × interceptions) ÷ attempts). The sum is his; reading each weight as passing yards is our restatement. On 20,000 random lines inside every cap it matched the capped formula to within a ten-trillionth of a point.
The 80-yard bonus for a touchdown is applied on top of the yards from the pass itself, which is already a completion. With attempts fixed, turning an incompletion into a touchdown pass of y yards adds 100 + y yard-equivalents, while turning it into an interception takes away 100. At 20 attempts, turning one completion into a touchdown adds 16.67 points, and one interception removes 20.83. A 2019 arXiv preprint by Albert and Angelis, finds it the most sensitive of three quarterback ratings to touchdowns, interceptions and completions.
College football's formula has no ceiling to hit
The NCAA's Football Statisticians' Manual (PDF dated January 2026) gives the college rating in §16: multiply yards per attempt by 8.4, add completion percentage, add 3.3 times touchdown percentage and subtract twice the interception percentage. It says the multipliers make "100.0 the average quarterback or team rating", and it states no caps or floors.
Divided by 8.4 into yards, our arithmetic gives a completion 11.90, a touchdown bonus 39.29 and an interception −23.81. The interception penalty is 0.61 of the touchdown bonus, against 1.25 in the professional formula.
The manual's sample line, 98 of 166 for 1,567 yards, 16 touchdowns and 7 interceptions, is printed as 161.71. Unrounded, we get 161.70; the manual carries each percentage to two decimal places. The same line rates 105.2 on the NFL formula. With nothing capped, a one-attempt line can rate anywhere from −731.6 to 1,261.6, figures already published elsewhere.
A lone 13-yard touchdown pass maxes out the formula
Perfection needs four thresholds at once: 77.5% completions, 12.5 yards an attempt, a touchdown on 11.875% of attempts and no interceptions. In whole numbers, our search gives these smallest perfect lines, all without an interception:
| Attempts | Completions at least | Touchdowns at least | Yards at least |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 1 | 1 | 13 |
| 5 | 4 | 1 | 63 |
| 10 | 8 | 2 | 125 |
| 20 | 16 | 3 | 250 |
| 30 | 24 | 4 | 375 |
| 40 | 31 | 5 | 500 |
One completed 13-yard touchdown pass is a perfect rating. At 12 yards the same pass is exactly 156.25, shown as 156.3. Past each cap more adds nothing: a single 99-yard completion with no touchdown works out at 118.75, shown as 118.8, the same as 20 of 30 for 300 yards, 3 touchdowns and 1 interception. The college formula gives that 99-yard pass 931.6.
Our NFL passer rating calculator works out the smallest perfect line for your number of attempts and marks each cap your line misses. Try 1 attempt, 1 completion, 13 yards, 1 touchdown and 0 interceptions, then change the yards to 12. Until 6 November 2026 it called any rating of 158.0 or more perfect, so 6 of 7 for 87 yards and a touchdown read "Perfect" with its yards part at 2.357. It also rated impossible lines such as 15 completions on 10 attempts, and filed the formula's own 66.7 under "Struggling". The revision of that date calls a line perfect only when all four parts are capped, drops the tier labels, and refuses several kinds of impossible line, among them more completions than attempts, yards without a completion and more than 99 yards a completion.
Average marks in every part leave headroom at 66.7
The Hall's page calls 1.000 the "average standard" in each part. A line at 1.000 in all four means 50% completions, 7.0 yards an attempt, touchdowns on 5% and interceptions on 5.5% of attempts, and it rates 66.7. That is the formula's design midpoint, and no average passer's rating in 1973 or today.
The figure is not ours: Wilson and Levine gave it in a 2009 San Diego State University technical report, calling 4 × 100/6 = 66.67 "the designed mean score". Above it, by our arithmetic, sit 91.7 points of headroom before the ceiling.
Rounding can hide a cap missed by half a yard
Take 27 attempts, 21 completions, 337 yards, 4 touchdowns and no interceptions. Three parts are capped, but the yards come to 12.48 an attempt, half a yard short of the 337.5 the cap needs. The exact rating is 158.256, which to one decimal reads 158.3, like a perfect line. It is the smallest such line in our search that avoids an exact tie at 158.25, where the rounding rule decides.
An interception is far harder to hide. With every other part capped, one interception needs about 5,000 attempts before the line rounds to 158.3 at all, and at exactly 5,000 it sits on the tie. Johnson's StatLib entry gives his dataset's ratings to the tenth, sometimes the hundredth to break ties, and the Dartmouth page says the rating is rounded to the nearest tenth. We could not confirm how the NFL itself rounds a line that falls just short of a cap.