Guide Finance 6 min read

How five Asian tax authorities time and price an employee share award

Singapore, Malaysia and Hong Kong tax a share award such as an RSU when it vests, on that day's market value, while the Philippines and Thailand word their tests differently. None of the first three taxes an award at a flat rate, so the tax it adds follows the income band it lands in, unlike the flat 22% a US employer can withhold.

Daniel Koh
Finance & Digital Economy Analyst
Published 19 Nov 2026, 9:37 AM (SGT)
Share:
A desk with a folder marked TAXES, stacked papers, coins and a folded banknote A desk with a folder marked TAXES, stacked papers, coins and a folded banknote Photo by MART PRODUCTION on Pexels
Advertisement

A share award, such as a restricted stock unit (RSU), is a promise of shares that an employer hands over once conditions like staying in the job are met. We set an award worth a quarter of salary against three resident tax schedules. In Hong Kong the tax it added never passed 17% of the award. In Singapore only the slice above S$500,000 of chargeable income was taxed at more than 22%. In Malaysia every ringgit above RM100,000 was taxed at 25% or more. The flat 22% a US employer can withhold on a vest matches none of them.

The rules for when an award is taxed are more consistent. Singapore, Malaysia and Hong Kong tax an award with vesting conditions when it vests, on that day's market value. The Philippines treats equity grants as pay "once exercised or availed of". Thailand's Revenue Department has taxed shares owned from grant in the year ownership passed, even under a sale ban.

Hong Kong's top band of 17% sits under the US flat rate at every income

Our arithmetic simply divides the tax added by an award worth 25% of salary by the award's value. It includes no reliefs or rebates, so it is no one's actual tax bill. Singapore's schedule is the IRAS page "Individual income tax rates" (updated 27 April 2026). Malaysia's is LHDN's Kadar Cukai page, whose latest table on 18 November 2026 was YA 2023–2025.

PlaceSalaryAwardTax addedShare of award
SingaporeS$60,000S$15,000S$1,0507.0%
SingaporeS$1,200,000S$300,000S$72,00024.0%
MalaysiaRM60,000RM15,000RM2,05013.7%
MalaysiaRM120,000RM30,000RM7,50025.0%
Hong KongHK$600,000HK$150,000HK$25,50017.0%
Hong KongHK$6,000,000HK$1,500,000HK$240,00016.0%

Hong Kong charges the lower of two amounts (GovHK, "Tax rates of salaries tax & personal assessment", read 18 November 2026). Progressive bands top out at 17% and the standard rate is 15% or 16%, so the lower of the two never charges more than 17% on an extra dollar. The HK$145,000 basic allowance for 2026/27 is from the IRD's "Allowances, Deductions and Tax Rate Table" (August 2026), as in our Hong Kong salaries tax guide.

Vesting day is when Singapore, Malaysia and Hong Kong tax an award

The IRAS e-Tax Guide on employee share plans (sixth edition, 30 January 2026) taxes an award with a vesting period and no selling restriction when the shares "are vested" (para 5.2). The IRD's DIPN 38 (revised March 2008) agrees through its "Back End" approach (paras 59–60), which suits shares forfeitable on leaving (para 61).

LHDN's Public Ruling No. 11/2012 names "Restricted Stock Unit Plan" among share award schemes (para 7.3.1). LHDN's index of rulings gives it no note of replacement and links a Malay text amended on 14 February 2017. In its Example 13, shares worth RM5.40 at grant and RM5.00 when ownership passes are taxed on RM5.00.

Philippine Revenue Regulations No. 13-2022 (dated October 2022) defines restricted stock units with a vesting period, yet taxes equity grants as compensation once "exercised or availed of" from 29 October 2022 according to Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 143-2022. Neither defines "availed of" for an RSU.

Advertisement

A sale ban alone leaves the tax at grant in Hong Kong and Thailand

Singapore is an outlier on this point. If shares carry a selling restriction, its e-Tax Guide's table reads "Taxable in the year when the selling restriction is lifted". DIPN 38 (paras 59–60) calls it "Upfront" when the employee holds shareholder rights and only a sale restriction remains, and taxes it at grant.

Thailand's evidence is two ruling letters, กค 0706/7560 (11 August 2004) and กค 0706/6667 (9 August 2005). In both, a foreign listed parent gave free shares carrying votes, a three-year sale ban and forfeiture on leaving. The Revenue Department held them employment income under section 40(1) of the Revenue Code. The 2005 letter added that they were taxable in the tax year ownership was received, sale conditions or not, and that a later breach did not remove the tax. The letters concern shares owned from grant, never an RSU.

Malaysia averages the day's high and low price for a listed share

PR 11/2012 values a listed share at its highest plus lowest price that day, divided by two (para 5.5.1). IRAS uses the open market price on the vesting date, less any price paid; DIPN 38 uses market value at vesting under its Back End approach (para 61). RMC 143-2022 takes the book value or fair market value at exercise, whichever is higher, less the price fixed at grant.

Withholding at the US supplemental rate runs high on low incomes and low on high ones

IRS Publication 15 (2026) lets an employer withhold a flat 22% of federal tax on supplemental wages such as a vest, and requires 37% past $1 million of them. Our RSU tax withholding calculator covers that US case only. Enter 500 shares at $60, $120,000 already paid, $0 of bonuses or earlier vests, a 5% state rate, single status and $180,000 of other income. It withholds $10,395 and sells 173.25 shares to cover. The vest adds $7,200 of federal tax against $6,600 withheld.

Our sweep of the same calculation took a single filer, a $30,000 vest, no wages already paid and no state tax. The 22% exceeded the tax the vest added up to $66,000 of other income, and fell short from $94,500. For joint filers the two points were $132,500 and $216,500.

Before a correction dated 18 November 2026, the calculator accepted other income below the wages already paid. On $300,000 paid and no other income, it promised about $5,180 back at filing, which those inputs cannot produce.

Moving abroad is judged by grant in Singapore and by days in Hong Kong

Under para 4.2 of the IRAS guide, an award granted while working in Singapore is taxable in full, "irrespective of where" the shares vest. DIPN 38 para 63 instead apportions by days in Hong Kong in the year of assessment of vesting, for an employee entitled to time apportionment.

For foreigners who cease employment and Singapore permanent residents leaving permanently, IRAS deems unvested awards income one month before cessation, or at grant if later (paras 2.5 and 12.2). For a permanent departure from Hong Kong, DIPN 38 para 74 sets out an election for deemed vesting.

Payroll collects in Malaysia and the Philippines, an assessment in Singapore and Hong Kong

The amended Malay text of PR 11/2012 has tax deducted under the monthly scheme (PCB) dalam bulan skim dilaksanakan, "in the month the scheme is exercised", or over up to 12 instalments (para 8(c)). The employee may instead pay with the return. Reading that month as an RSU's vesting month is our inference. RMC 143-2022 has the Philippine employer report the compensation on BIR Forms 1601-C, 1604-C and 2316.

IRAS describes a tax bill, payable within one month, for the preceding calendar year ("Basic guide for new individual taxpayers", updated 16 April 2026). Its stock-options page (updated 2 March 2026) offers GIRO instalments or deferral of up to five years, with interest. In Hong Kong, the employer reports the award on IR56 returns (DIPN 38 para 83) and the tax is assessed directly. A closing note in para 84 observes no unfairness in taxing share awards "before he can sell the shares for cash".

Advertisement
Daniel Koh
Finance & Digital Economy Analyst

Daniel Koh covers fintech, digital payments, banking technology, and ASEAN digital-economy regulation for RECATOOLS.

View author profile → · Editorial policy

About this byline Daniel Koh is a RECATOOLS editorial persona for finance and digital-economy analysis. Articles are produced and reviewed under RECATOOLS editorial supervision.

Corrections policy

Advertisement